Asher and quarterback Chase have been secretly dating for six months—Chase has never gone public with their relationship, instead playing the perfect boyfriend to Asher's sister Daisy. Asher's nude photos leak around campus, stolen by Daisy from Chase's phone. Chase tells Asher to keep quiet and keeps using him. Hockey captain Finn opens Instagram in front of everyone: "Want to date me? Follow me first." The next day, he takes Asher's hand in the hallway—fingers intertwined—for everyone to see. Daisy fakes a nut allergy attack to frame Asher, and Asher shoves her head into a fountain. Chase loses the game and screams at Daisy on the sidelines—his golden-boy image crumbles completely. Finn wins the game and says to the camera: "Our goalie held it down alone for two periods. I don't want him carrying it by himself anymore." Everyone knows what he means.